A sale price that is higher than the regular price

What it is

On a product page, your store shows a crossed-out “before” price next to the current price. In Shopify this is the compare-at price.

It goes wrong in a few ways:

  • the crossed-out price is lower than the current price
  • the crossed-out price is the same as the current price, so nothing is on sale
  • the price is zero
  • almost everything in the catalogue is “on sale”, all the time

How it costs sales

Shoppers notice. A “sale” that costs more than the original looks like a mistake, or a trick. Either way, they trust the store less, and trust is what a small store is selling.

It can also confuse Google. If the price in the page’s hidden product data doesn’t match the price a shopper sees, Google may flag the product in its shopping listings.

Check it yourself in 2 minutes

  1. Open your best-selling collection.
  2. Find the products that show a crossed-out price.
  3. For each one, check: is the crossed-out price higher than the price beside it?
  4. Scroll through the rest of the collection. Is everything on sale? Is anything at 0?
  5. In your Shopify admin, open a flagged product. The crossed-out price is the “compare-at price” field in its pricing section. Empty it if there’s no sale.

If a “sale” has ended, clear the compare-at price. If it’s meant to be on sale, make the numbers right.

How we watch it

Every night we read the price list your store publishes: the first 250 products, for now. We flag any product where the crossed-out price is lower than the current price.

Some odd prices are on purpose. A product sold as a bundle may look strange. So we check a second time, and we tell you what we see. We don’t change prices. Prices are yours.

The first time we see a new price problem, we say so in the monthly letter or, if it’s serious, as an alert. We also notice when a price jumps overnight, so that you can tell whether you meant it.


Get the free check